The five scales side by side
All prices and specs below come from each brand's own US store, checked on 18 November 2026. We haven't tested these scales ourselves. The comparison is built from published specs, independent research on bioelectrical impedance, and owner reports.
| Scale | Price | Electrodes | Segmental | Extras | Subscription | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hume Pod 2.0 | $249 (list $383) | 8, hands and feet | Arms, trunk, legs | Bluetooth only; Apple Health sync | Free app; Hume Plus $9.99/mo optional | Shop |
| Withings Body Scan | $499.95 | Handle plus feet | 5 body zones | 6-lead ECG, vascular age, Wi-Fi | Free baseline; Withings+ $9.95/mo optional | |
| Withings Body Comp | $229.95 | Feet only | No | Vascular age, standing heart rate, Wi-Fi | Free baseline; Withings+ optional | |
| Renpho MorphoScan Nova | $199.99 (list $219.99) | 8, handle on a cord | Upper and lower body | 50+ metrics on scale and app | Renpho Health app required | |
| Wyze Scale X | $32.98 (list $38.98) | 4, feet only | No | 13 metrics, AAA batteries | Wyze app |
Body composition scales compared, US prices checked 18 November 2026
Foot-only or 8-point: why the handle matters
Every scale here uses bioelectrical impedance analysis. A small current passes through your body and the scale measures the resistance. Water-rich lean tissue conducts well and fat conducts poorly, so an equation turns that resistance into fat and muscle estimates. Our guide to BIA scale accuracy explains the method.
On a foot-only scale, the current goes up one leg and down the other. Your arms and most of your trunk sit outside that path, so the scale estimates them from your legs and your profile. A handle adds contacts at the hands, which lets the scale measure arms, legs and trunk as separate segments.
That difference shows up in the research.
A 2023 study in the British Journal of Nutrition tested fifteen BIA devices against a four-compartment model, a stricter reference than DEXA alone. Hand-to-foot 8-electrode devices, along with a few foot-only ones, were the best at tracking change over 12 to 16 weeks. Single readings were another story. Across the group, the average error ranged from about -3.5 to +11.7 percentage points of body fat.
Hume Pod 2.0: the cheapest 8-electrode scale with a strong app

Hume Health
Hume Pod
The Pod 2.0 is $249 in Hume's Black Friday sale, shown against $383, and the banner says the sale ends 22 November.
You stand on the plate and hold a handle, giving 8 contact points. Hume lists 45+ metrics in the app, including segmental fat and muscle, visceral fat, body water and a metabolic age score. Capacity is 441 lb and the battery recharges, rated at up to a year per charge.
The weak points are practical. It connects over Bluetooth only, so your phone needs to be nearby with the app open. Owners on Amazon and Trustpilot report connection trouble and slow support. Hume claims 99% body-fat accuracy against DEXA, citing a Socotech study we couldn't find published.
Our Hume Pod 2.0 review goes into the owner reports and the accuracy question in detail. For current offers, see the Hume discount code page.
Withings Body Scan: the most complete, and the most expensive
At $499.95 the Body Scan costs twice as much as the Hume Pod. That's a lot. For the extra money you get a retractable handle that also records a 6-lead ECG for atrial fibrillation screening, a vascular age estimate, and an electrodermal activity score from the foot plates. It reads muscle and fat in five body zones.
It syncs over Wi-Fi or Bluetooth and recognises up to 8 users. No phone needed at weigh-in.
Withings says baseline metrics and trends stay free. Withings+ costs $9.95 a month or $99.50 a year and adds the Health Assistant, scores and cardiologist review of ECGs. The site showed a Black Friday banner but no discount on the Body Scan itself when we checked.
One correction to a claim you'll see elsewhere. Hume's own comparison chart describes the Withings Body Scan as foot-only with 4 electrodes. Withings' product page shows a wall-mounted handle and five-zone segmental readings, so that description doesn't match. We set the two side by side in Hume Pod vs Withings Body Scan.
Withings also sells a newer BodyScan 2 at $599.95 with 12 electrodes and a display in the handle, and a BodyFit at $279.95 with 8 electrodes and no ECG. The BodyFit is the closest Withings rival to the Hume Pod on price.
Withings Body Comp: foot-only, with heart extras
The Body Comp is $229.95. It has no handle, so it reads through the feet only, and it gives whole-body rather than segmental figures: fat, muscle, bone, water, visceral fat and BMR. What it adds over a cheap foot scale is vascular age, a standing heart rate, Wi-Fi sync and the Withings app.
It runs on four AAA batteries, which Withings rates at about 15 months. If you want a scale that syncs without your phone and you don't need limb-by-limb data, it's a sensible pick. If segmental readings are the point, the Hume Pod costs about $20 more and has hand electrodes.
It's worth knowing that an older Withings foot-only model, the Body Cardio, was one of three smart scales in a French hospital study against DEXA. Weight was close to exact. Fat mass was off by a median of 3.7 kg for that scale.
The Body Comp is a newer design, so the result doesn't transfer directly, but it shows the ceiling for foot-only BIA.
Renpho MorphoScan Nova: the budget handle scale
Renpho's MorphoScan Nova is $199.99 against $219.99. It has 8 electrodes, with a sensor handle on a retractable cord, and Renpho says it reads upper and lower body and shows over 50 metrics on the scale and in the app. It measures at two frequencies, 20 kHz and 100 kHz.
Renpho's product page says the scale must be used with the Renpho Health app. We didn't find a required subscription on that page. Renpho's safety notes are also more cautious than Hume's: pregnant users and people with pacemakers or metal implants are told to use it for weight only, with shoes on.
Cheapest handle scale here, then. The trade-off is a less established track record for the Nova specifically, and less published detail on the algorithm than Withings gives.
Wyze Scale X: the budget pick for weight and trends
The Wyze Scale X is $32.98 in Wyze's Black Friday sale, against $38.98. It has 4 foot electrodes on ITO-coated glass, reports 13 body composition metrics in the app, handles 11 to 400 lb, and recognises up to 8 users. It runs on AAA batteries rated at up to 22 months.
Buy it for accurate weight and a rough body fat trend. Don't buy it for muscle in each arm, because a foot-only scale can't measure that. If a $33 scale gets you weighing in daily, it may do more for your progress than a $500 one you use twice a week.
Accuracy limits that apply to every scale here
Both Hume and Withings quote 99% figures against DEXA. Neither number tells you how far your own reading might be from a scan, and neither comes from a study we could read in full. Treat both as company claims. We would.
The independent picture is consistent. In a study of three InBody analysers, the gym-grade 8-electrode machines, readings were very repeatable but consistently underestimated body fat compared with DEXA. The European nutrition society's BIA guidance says BIA works best in healthy people with normal hydration and is least reliable at extremes of BMI.
So all five are trend tools. That's fine. Weigh in at the same time each morning, before food or exercise, and judge progress over weeks. If you need one precise number, a DEXA scan is the reference.
Which one to buy

Hume Health
Hume Pod
For most people who want segmental data, the Hume Pod 2.0 at $249 is the best value while the sale runs, provided Bluetooth-only sync doesn't bother you. The Renpho MorphoScan Nova is $50 cheaper with a similar electrode layout if you'd rather save the money.
Pick the Withings Body Scan if you'll use the ECG and want Wi-Fi sync, and can justify $499.95. Pick the Body Comp if you want Withings' app and Wi-Fi but don't need limb readings. Pick the Wyze Scale X if weight and a basic trend are enough.
If you're weighing the Pod against a wearable too, what Hume charges for everything lists the Band and bundle prices, and the Hume Health brand page covers the company.
Disclosure: we earn a commission if you buy a Hume product through our links. Withings, Renpho and Wyze pay us nothing, and their links here are plain links to their own stores.

