The verdict first

Hume Health
Hume Pod
If you want body composition, fat versus muscle, visceral fat and left-right symmetry, buy the Hume Pod 2.0. At $249 it does the segmental job for half the money, and the 45-day return window is generous.
If you want a heart check built into the morning weigh-in, buy the Withings Body Scan. The 6-lead ECG for atrial fibrillation is the one feature here with an FDA clearance behind it, and nothing on the Pod replaces it. You pay $250 more for that. The extra money buys heart features; the body fat numbers are no better.
A plain disclosure: we earn a commission if you buy a Hume product through our links. We earn nothing from Withings, and the Withings links here go to its own store with no tracking. We also haven't used either scale. This comparison is built from both brands' specs and pages, published data and owner reports.
Side by side
Prices and specs read from humehealth.com and withings.com on 18 November 2026, US storefronts. Hume localises prices by country, so a visitor outside the US sees different numbers. Tap the Hume row to open its store.
| Scale | Price today | Segmental | Heart features | App upgrade | Warranty | Returns | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hume Pod 2.0 | $249 (shown against $383) | Yes: 8 hand and foot sensors, arms, legs and trunk | Heart rate sensor, no ECG | Hume Plus, $9.99/month, optional | 1 year; 10-year cover $46 at checkout | 45 days | Shop |
| Withings Body Scan | $499.95 (no markdown) | Yes: handle, muscle and fat in 5 body zones | 6-lead ECG (FDA cleared), Vascular Age, standing heart rate | Withings+, $9.95/month or $99.50/year, optional | 2 years | 30 days |
Hume Pod 2.0 vs Withings Body Scan, checked 18 November 2026
Price, and what the Black Friday offers actually do
Hume's Pod 2.0 page shows $249 against $383, under a site banner reading "Black Friday, up to 50% off". That works out to about 35% off the Pod. The up-to-50% figure applies elsewhere in the store, so don't expect it on the scale. Our Hume discount code page tracks what changes on the day itself, 27 November.
We'd treat the $383 the way we treat every permanent reference price: as an anchor. The useful number is $249, and the useful comparison is with Withings' cash price rather than Hume's own struck-through one.
Withings lists the Body Scan at $499.95 and wasn't discounting it on 18 November. Its Black Friday mechanic is different: sign up on withings.com and you get an extra $30 off orders of $300 or more. That takes the Body Scan to $469.95, still nearly double the Pod.
One trap to avoid: Withings now also sells a BodyScan 2 at $599.95. Reviews of "the Withings Body Scan" written in 2023 and 2024 mean the first model, which launched at $399.95 and has since gone up. Check which one a review is talking about before you trust its price comparison.
Electrodes and segmental readings
This is where older comparisons go wrong. The original Hume Body Pod was a feet-only scale, and plenty of articles still say only the Withings reads the upper body. The Pod 2.0 changed that. Hume's page lists eight hand and foot sensors and a handle you hold during the scan, and it reports arms, legs and trunk separately.
The Withings Body Scan has a retractable handle too, stored in the base and attached by a cable. Its electrodes sit on the handle and the platform, and Withings reports muscle and fat mass across five body zones.
On hardware, then, it's close. Both send current through hands and feet, so both can see a weak arm or a difference between legs, which is the main reason to pay for a segmental scale at all. A feet-only scale mostly measures your lower body and estimates the rest.
The Pod 2.0 also adds a contact check before each reading and solid metal sensors in place of coated ones, according to Hume. Those are sensible fixes for repeatability. We can't verify how much they help, and Hume's own spec list describes the sensing as "8-frequency" in one place and "dual-frequency" in another, which is worth asking support about.
Metrics: what each one measures

Hume Health
Hume Pod
Hume markets the Pod 2.0 as tracking 45 metrics. The ones that matter are body fat, visceral fat, muscle mass, skeletal muscle, body water, bone mass, metabolic age and segmental symmetry. Many of the remaining metrics are derived from those, so a long list doesn't give you that many separate measurements.
Withings' spec sheet lists body fat percentage, total body water, muscle mass, bone mass, a visceral fat index and basal metabolic rate, plus the segmental split. On body composition alone, the two report roughly the same things.
Withings has more modes. It recognises up to eight users automatically and offers Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby and Eyes Closed settings.
Hume lets several accounts share one Pod, but each person weighs in through their own phone app, and the scale talks to one phone at a time over Bluetooth. The Body Scan also has Wi-Fi, so it syncs without your phone nearby. For a busy household that difference is real.
ECG and nerve health: the Withings-only features
The Body Scan records a 6-lead ECG while you hold the handle and flags possible atrial fibrillation. Withings announced its FDA clearance in August 2023, filed under the name Scan Monitor 2.0. Nothing else on either scale has one.
Vascular Age is an estimate of arterial stiffness from pulse wave velocity. It's a reasonable wellness number. Make decisions with a doctor, never from the scale alone.
The third feature is the one marketed as nerve health. On the US page it's now called an Electrodermal Activity Score: the platform measures sweat gland activity in your feet, using a method that came out of the clinical Sudoscan device for small fibre neuropathy.
The clearance covers the ECG, not this score, and owner reviews often say the number is hard to act on. Treat it as interesting rather than diagnostic.
Hume's Pod lists a built-in heart rate sensor and a "heart health" item among its metrics. There's no ECG and no AFib detection. If the heart features are why you're looking at this pair, the decision is already made.
Apps and subscriptions: Withings+ vs Hume Plus
Neither scale makes you subscribe to see your readings, which counts for a lot in this category.
Hume's FAQ says the app is free for weighing in and viewing body composition, and that Hume Plus adds coaching and deeper reports at $9.99 a month. If you also own or plan to buy the Hume Band, the same app joins sleep, recovery and body composition data. Our Hume Health review covers what sits behind that upgrade across both devices.
Withings+ is $9.95 a month or $99.50 a year, with the first month free and set to renew unless you cancel. The most concrete thing it adds is a cardiologist review of your ECG within 24 hours. It also adds a Readiness score, a health assistant and a nutritionist video call. Withings says the core scale readings stay free.
Over two years, a buyer who wants the paid tier pays roughly $249 plus $240 for Hume, or $499.95 plus $199 for Withings on the annual plan. The gap narrows, but the Pod stays cheaper.
Accuracy: what "99%" means on both boxes
Hume claims "99% body-fat accuracy compared with DEXA" and cites an independent study by Socotech putting the Pod within plus or minus 2% of a DEXA scan. Withings claims a "99% correlation with DEXA". Both need reading carefully.
Correlation measures whether two methods rise and fall together across a group. It says nothing about whether your own reading matches your DEXA. Any scale can correlate at 0.99 and still read you three points high. A plus or minus 2% band on body fat is plausible for a good impedance scale under controlled conditions, and still a wide band when you're tracking a two-point change.
Both scales use bioelectrical impedance, which estimates body composition from how current moves through water in tissue. Hydration, a recent meal, a workout or the time of day can move the result, as our guide to impedance scale accuracy explains. We found no independent head-to-head study of these two scales against DEXA.
In practice, weigh in at the same time each morning, before food or exercise, and read the four-week trend. Used that way, either scale will tell you whether you're losing fat or muscle. Neither replaces a periodic DEXA scan if you need an exact figure.
Which one to buy
Buy the Hume Pod 2.0 if body composition is the point: weight loss, a GLP-1 medication where you want to watch muscle, training, or rehab where left-right symmetry matters. It covers the segmental job at half the price and gives you 45 days to return it.
Buy the Withings Body Scan if you want the ECG, have a reason to watch for AFib, or need a scale that several people can use without their phones. You pay for heart features, and they're well built.
If you're still choosing between more than two scales, our best body composition scales guide adds Renpho and the cheaper Withings models. For the Pod on its own, including what owners report after months of use, read the Hume Pod 2.0 review.

